I searched for decades to find a good toothpaste that did not have mint or menthol flavoring nor coloring. Yes, some of us HATE MINT/MENTHOL. I was thrilled to find Spry a couple of years ago, but the latest order delivered 4 tubes of something that is a shadow of the former product. The new formulation is mentholy-tasting (tho not stated in the ingredients which are different that before) with barely detectable cinnamon flavor. It's also now goopy so when using with electric toothbrush, it completely liquifies in a few seconds and runs out of your mouth. The good news is that the size is 25% larger. So I now have 3+ boxes of goopy, yucky-tasting stuff and 25 % more of it! I've already ordered a replacement: cinnamon & clove toothpaste from Tom's of Maine that they guarantee contains NO MINT NOR MENTHOL. The last Tom's I tried was kind of goopy, but I'll live with that rather than face every morning tasting menthol/mint.